Sell Your Cards
We buy singles, collections, and bulk. Get a fair offer — book an appointment, meet us at a show, or submit your list online for a quote.
How It Works
- 1Submit Your ListFill out the form with your card list or upload a CSV.
- 2Get Your OfferWe'll review and send you our best offer within two business days.
- 3Ship or Meet at a ShowAccept the offer and ship your cards to us, or bring them to any tradeshow we attend.
- 4Get PaidCash, PayPal, Venmo, or store credit (20% bonus).
Condition Guide
Card shows minimal to no wear. Corners are sharp, edges are clean, and the surface has no visible scratches or scuffs. Card looks fresh from a pack.
All buylist offers are evaluated individually. Final offer may vary based on current market conditions and demand.
Book an Appointment / Submit Your List
What We Buy
Propaganda MTG purchases all types of Magic: The Gathering product. Whether you're selling a curated Commander collection, a binder of Modern staples, or boxes of unsorted bulk — we're interested.
- SinglesRares, mythics, uncommons, and commons in any condition
- Complete CollectionsAny size, sorted or unsorted — we handle the work
- Bulk LotsCommons, uncommons, basic lands, tokens
- FoilsRegular foils, extended art, showcase, retro frame
- Sealed ProductBooster boxes, collector boxes, bundles, precons, Secret Lairs
- Foreign LanguageJapanese, German, Italian, and more
- Damaged CardsCreased, water-damaged, heavily played — we still buy them
- Store InventoriesClosing your LGS? We buy full store stocks
Why Sell to Propaganda MTG?
Competitive Pricing
We base offers on current TCGPlayer market values and pay fairly for every card.
Any Size Collection
No minimum. Whether it's 50 cards or 50,000, we'll make an offer.
Fast Turnaround
Offers within two business days, payment issued immediately after verification.
No Sorting Required
Don't want to sort your collection? No problem. We handle it.
In-Person Option
Meet us at tradeshows nationwide for same-day evaluation and cash payment.
All Conditions Accepted
From Near Mint to Damaged, we buy cards in any condition.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much is my Magic: The Gathering collection worth?
Every collection is different. Propaganda MTG evaluates each collection individually based on card condition, rarity, format demand, and current TCGPlayer market values. Submit your collection through our sell form and we'll provide a competitive offer within two business days.
Do you buy bulk Magic cards?
Yes. Propaganda MTG buys bulk commons, uncommons, rares, foils, and mixed lots. We buy collections of any size — there is no minimum. Whether you have 100 cards or 100,000 cards, we'll make an offer.
What conditions of Magic cards do you buy?
We buy Magic cards in any condition — Near Mint (NM), Lightly Played (LP), Moderately Played (MP), Heavily Played (HP), and Damaged. Cards in worse condition are discounted from market value, but we still buy them.
How do I sell my Magic collection to Propaganda MTG?
Fill out the sell request form on this page. Tell us about your collection — what's in it, approximate size, and any notable cards. We'll review it and get back to you with an offer within two business days. You can also bring your collection to any tradeshow we attend for an in-person evaluation.
How fast do you pay after receiving a Magic collection?
For in-person evaluations at tradeshows, you can walk away with payment the same day. For shipped collections, we evaluate within a few business days of receiving them and issue payment immediately after.
Can I sell my Magic collection in person?
Yes. Propaganda MTG attends tradeshows nationwide where you can bring your collection for an in-person evaluation and same-day cash payment. We don't have a physical storefront, but we're regularly on the road — check our events page for upcoming show dates and locations.
Do you buy sealed Magic: The Gathering product?
Yes. We buy sealed booster boxes, collector boxes, bundles, preconstructed decks, From the Vault sets, Secret Lair drops, and any other sealed Magic product. We also buy mixed lots of sealed and singles together.